Into the fray: US and Israeli Jews deeply divided on life and death issues.

The policy preferences of much of US Jewry seem even more paradoxically perverse—as they are undeniably lending support to political regimes that comprise the diametric opposite of the enlightened liberal values the purport to cherish.

The dichotomy over the US elections between Jews in America and Jews in Israel is stark and startling. While over 70 % of US Jews supported the Democratic candidate, Joe Biden, almost 70% of Israeli Jews prefer the GOP incumbent, Donald Trump.

credit: +972magazine

Plausible amity; puzzling enmity

It is, of course, not hard to understand the Israeli position.  After all, despite Trump’s sometimes un-endearing personal demeanor, he has produced a long list of highly favorable policy decisions for Israel, that began to fundamentally change the Middle East and the basic parameters of the Arab-Israeli conflict—including:  Recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel;  moving the US embassy to the city;  defunding URWA (The United Nations Relief & Works Agency—that perpetuates the Palestinian-Arab refugee problem);  cutting funding to the Palestinian Authority (PA); acknowledging the legality of Jewish communities in Judaea-Samaria (aka “The West Bank”);  recognizing Israeli sovereignty over the strategically vital Golan Heights; and pulling out of the perilously defective Iran nuclear deal—imposing harsh sanctions on Tehran’s tyrannical theocracy, and driving its faltering economy to the brink of collapse.

On the other hand, fathoming US Jewry animus to Trump is considerably more difficult.  Indeed, putting aside for the moment Trump’s robust support for their kinfolk in the Jewish nation-state, one might have reasonably expected that many domestic policy initiatives launched by Trump would have been eagerly embraced by much of the US Jewish community, who traditionally subscribe to Left-leaning liberal political views .

“Palestinians, desperate for a Biden victory…”

After all, Trump introduced prison reform, and brought unemployment to record lows for minorities. Likewise, he appointed the first woman ever to head the CIA, the second woman ever as Secretary of Homeland Security, and a woman to the bench of the US Supreme Court.  Despite fierce opposition from large drug manufacturers, he has pushed for lower prices for prescription drugs, signing several executive orders towards this goal.  All of these should have militated toward drawing greater support from the wider Jewish electorate.  Nonetheless, the overwhelming majority of US Jews chose to adhere to their almost Pavlovian anti-GOP knee-jerk reaction.

But it is in field of foreign relations that US Jewish backing of a Biden presidency bodes particularly ill.

For while the Trump administration was prepared to confront Israel’s principal enemies with firm resolve, it appears that a Biden administration leans towards charting a course that would be far more considerate of Israel’s foes—and far more compliant in meeting their demands.

Indeed, one election day headline proclaimed “Palestinians, desperate for a Biden victory, hold their breath as America votes”

In similar vein the New York Times wrote: “The Palestinians are counting on a Trump defeat…They don’t even want to think about Plan B… Isolated diplomatically and running out of money… the Palestinians are looking to Tuesday’s election more desperate than ever for a change in Washington.”

Iran: Biden the ‘more promising’ candidate

Thus, Nabil Shaath, a senior adviser to PA President Mahmoud Abbas declared: “He has been the worst American president as far as our cause is concerned…The most important thing as far as we are concerned is that Trump goes”; while PA Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh made the point even more bluntly: “If we are going to live another four years with President Trump, God help us…”

Likewise, the Ayatollahs in Iran harbor a strong preference for Biden. Thus, in a piece headlined: “Why Iran sees Biden as the ‘more promising’ candidate in the U.S. election” CBS News conveyed: “Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif has indicated to CBS News that the Islamic Republic’s leadership would prefer Joe Biden win the U.S. election…”

Bloomberg echoed a similar assessment: “Joe Biden… has signalled he’ll seek to bring Iran back into the 2015 nuclear accord the U.S. brokered…under Barack Obama. That means the economic sanctions President Donald Trump imposed — and tightened further this week—could eventually be eased…”

The Abraham Accords & US Jewry’s indifference to life-and-death issues

A Biden administration would be likely to gravely undermine the emerging Trump-brokered peace/normalization process between Israel and several Arab countries such as the UAE, Bahrain, Sudan and perhaps Saudi Arabia.  According to a recent paper by a leading Israeli strategic studies center: “Joe Biden’s intended policies for the Middle East would completely undermine any existing potential for progress toward normalization between Israel and Saudi Arabia. It would be stopped dead in its tracks.  This is because Biden and his advisors have stated unambiguously that they intend to reverse all the…aspects of current US Middle East policy—in other words, all the policies that allowed the Abraham Accords to come to fruition.”

These matters —Iran’s nuclear program, the conflict with the Palestinians and peace with the wider Arab word—are all life and death issues for Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people.

Yet not only do their kinfolk in the US seem largely indifferent to them; they seem stubbornly bent on support for a candidate committed to policies benignly accommodating to Israel’s mortal enemies.

Touting tyranny: The perverse paradox of US Jewry 

Seen in this light, the policy preferences of much of US Jewry seem even more paradoxically perverse—as they are undeniably lending support to political regimes that comprise the diametric opposite of the enlightened liberal values the purport to cherish.

This is something that Israel cannot ignore, and with arguably greater support for it in America emanating from non-Jewish sectors, it may be soon compelled to recalibrate its relationship with US Jewry—or, at least significant portions of it.


Martin Sherman is the founder & executive director of the Israel Institute for Strategic Studies





Check Also

Yes, truly, Israel is not Canada- Opinion

We, like you, treasure democracy, humaneness, justice, and civil and human rights. We are not …


  1. Israel is fast becoming either irrelevant to American Jews or is seen as the source of all problems in the mideast, despite the demonstrable good Trump has done. The generation that saw the rebirth of the Jewish nation-state in the aftermath of the Holocaust and the generation that witnessed another miraculous Israeli victory over Arab armies in 1967 are fading away, replaced by their grandchildren and great grandchildren who were indoctrinated with liberalism since birth.

    They reflexively cleave to progressive causes and abhor anything GOP. Do black lives matter? Of course! So do Jewish lives and police lives, but not in the Left’s zero sum game. While Trump is excoriated for some white supremicists backing him, all the Democratic candidates genuflected before Farrakhan, arguably the most hateful racist alive today. And four of his ardent followers sit in Congress driving national policy. This is s huge problem!

    • The problem is, in my opinion, many American Jews appear to want to distance themselves from Judaism in general.
      I don’t think your younger generation haven’t been taught the history of Israel and what she’s had to endure to survive.
      In this country something like 60% of Jewish children attend Jewish day school. The remainder in public schools have a Jewish education funded by the community.
      Outside of Israel we took more Holocaust survivors than any other country. Our children study it.
      Our Left aren’t as hate filled as yours appears to be.
      The situation in the US at this point in time is more than worrying.

  2. Jacob Wajsbort

    The real question is how could ANYONE have rationally supported the Biden side. Higher taxes either by raising taxes or reducing tax breaks for lower income earners, increased energy costs, removing incentives for US manufacturers to remain in the US, increased healthcare costs (documented by-product of Obamacare), cancel culture, wokeness, critical race theory etc – is there anything for a rational, normal person to like or support? (Just ask Bill Shorten about bad policy.) And then the crazy foreign policies that will adversely impact the world! However everyone knows that the policies were irrelevant with such planned widespread voting and vote counting ‘irregularities’ that appear to be the real plan to winning the Presidency.