Antisemitic conspiracy theorist in New Zealand media.

New Zealand’s role as a sponsor of UN Security Council Resolution 2334 and the resulting spat between New Zealand and Israel has sparked some intense debate in the New Zealand media. It’s also unleashed some particularly nasty and downright weird characters giving voice to their hatred of Israel.

credit: The National Business Review.

For example, Patrick Smellie, in the Fairfax Media-owned Taranaki Daily News, opines that Israel may wage ‘war’ on New Zealand through cyber warfare targeting “key elements of New Zealand infrastructure – telecommunications and electricity networks, secure communications channels for diplomats and defence personnel, and the like.”

It doesn’t come as much of a shock that underneath the piece is a note stating that the “article has been edited for clarity since it was first published.”

Not much clarity there.

But worse is to be found in the New Zealand Herald affiliated Hawke’s Bay Today in an appalling opinion piece by Malcolm Eves.

“God’s chosen people”.

First, we have the reference to “God’s chosen people”:

credit:Good Fun Bike Rides.

The Christians are never going to be persuaded that Israel behaves as a rogue state responsible for the merciless slaughter of thousands of Palestinians under the leadership of Netanyahu and the other Israeli Prime Ministers before him because they believe that the Jews are God’s chosen people (meaning they can do what they like and it must be God’s will), so whatever the crime, they look to excuse the appalling behaviour.”Malcolm Eves

The abuse of the concept of the “chosen people” refers specifically to Jews and is commonly employed by antisemites to falsely assert that Jews claim to be superior to non-Jews not only in a theological sense but also in a racial one.

As Joseph Telushkin asks:

Does Judaism believe that chosenness endows Jews with special rights in the way racist ideologies endow those born into the “right race”? Not at all. The most famous verse in the Bible on the subject of chosenness says the precise opposite: “You alone have I singled out of all the families of the earth. That is why I call you to account for all your iniquities” (Amos 3:2). Chosenness is so unconnected to any notion of race that Jews believe that the Messiah himself will descend from Ruth, a non-­Jewish woman who converted to Judaism.” Joseph Telushkin

“American neocon Zionist Jews”

Then Eves moves on to some tried and tested antisemitic tropes:

It’s impossible for Palestinians to negotiate, no one “negotiates” with Netanyahu, in a normal give and take manner, it’s only his way and he cares not one bit for global condemnation of his assault on Palestinians as he has the American neocon Zionist Jews politically behind him and the hoodwinked US taxpayer haplessly funding him to the tune of billions of dollars each year calculated at about $US11 million each day.”Malcolm Eves

The conflation of American neoconservatism with Zionists and Jews is the product of a conspiracy theory promoted on extremist and neo-Nazi websites that a ‘cabal’ of Jews is controlling US foreign policy. That US taxpayers are being “hoodwinked” by these cunning Jews further plays into the classical anti-Semitic trope on display.

Antisemitic conspiracy theories.

And just to prove that Eves is a real dye in the wool conspiracy theorist, there’s this:

More importantly is understanding the bigger picture of war in the Middle East and the Zionist plan for greater Israel. Also known as the “Yinon Plan”, according to the founding father of Zionism Theodor Herzl, “the area of the Jewish State stretches: “From the Brook of Egypt to the Euphrates.”

According to Rabbi Fischmann, “The Promised Land extends from the River of Egypt up to the Euphrates, it includes parts of Syria and Lebanon”. This is being played out now with the destruction of Iraq and now Syria by the US backing the al-Qaeda rebels as they have now openly admitted.Malcolm Eves

This utterly ridiculous “greater Israel” charge is a staple of numerous anti-Semitic websites that have twisted reality to falsely claim a Zionist plan to turn the Middle East into Arab proxy states controlled by Israel.

As outlined in the Jewish Press:

The theory is based on an article that was published in the 1982 winter edition of Kivunim, a “Journal for Judaism and Zionism,” by Oded Yinon, who writes that the agreements in the Camp David Accords should not be honored, and discusses how Arab states will be eroded along ethnic and religious lines. This article might otherwise have been forgotten, but conspiracy theorists got their hands on it and ran with the ball. The theoretical stance outlined by Yinon was expanded perhaps beyond the originator’s wildest dreams, so much so, that Arab conspiracy theorists are now ready to blame internal discord in their countries on a Zionist plot to destabilize their nations and to gobble them up as part of a future Israeli colonialist empire.”Jewish Press

That Eves links an article from 1982 to Theodor Herzl who died in 1904 merely demonstrates that Eves doesn’t even have the intellectual capacity to effectively lift content from anti-Semitic websites without making a fool of himself.

Malcolm Eves’ appalling display of antisemitism and conspiracy theories belongs in the most fringe corners of the internet. That this has been reproduced in a local newspaper affiliated to the mainstream New Zealand Herald should be an embarrassment to the Herald’s proprietors.

Columnists are entitled to legitimately criticize Israel in the media. Spreading antisemitism, conspiracies and lies crosses the line from free speech to hate speech.

Shalom.Kiwi’s contributors are a mix of Māori, Pakeha, Jewish and non-Jewish New Zealanders, who have all spent considerable time in Israel.
This article was orginally published on HonestReporting.

Check Also

Closing Jews Down Under Website

With a heavyish heart I am closing down the website after ten years.        It is …


  1. New Zealand appears to be at approximately the same level of political maturity as regional Queensland in 1956.

    • Ah, the good old days Geoff….when Labor Premier Vince Gair was at the helm in Queensland…my heart still pines for those wonderful, clearly defined times….

      • Vince Gair.

        Ah yes.

        I had almost forgotten about him.

        Do you remember compulsory milk in schools, class sizes over seventy and teachers were required to clean the kids’ toilets as part of their duties?

        Restaurants were not allowed to sell wine because it competed with the hotels which were not allowed to open on Sundays. In fact no one was allowed to open on law.

        Peanut butter had to be named “peanut paste” because it was against the law to call anything butter unless it was dairy.. Margarine had to be labelled “for cooking purposes only.

        And there were no Protestants in the Labor Party and no Catholics in the Liberal Party which in any event was junior to the Country Party.

        The state government used to ban films, books and magazines. ..

        Now I’m thinking the sixties

        • Boom Boom Geoff…ya got me…but it taught us Queenslanders toughness and resilience…and if you were a from the Masonic (Protestant) Lodge you got ahead in the Public Service, and us Hibernian Catholics lived a miserable life…

          You know your subject.

          Still friends Geoff…just being a now very old Queenslander, I couldn’t pass the opportunity….Cheers

  2. Hi Shirlee…..yep, I feel the same way about Geoff…just from his comments at times….I was horsing around, trying to stick up for the old home state…but Geoff knows Qld as well as I do. His summary gave me nostalgia pangs….Sundays in Qld in those times was as dead as any cemetery…and Margarine….he is correct – it was near reviled as something evil. He knew what he was writing about. Lol.

    • His mother was part of the founding members of the Gold Coast Orthodox synagogue.
      Lovely lady, who I had the privilege to meet a few years ago.