Oz Torah: Ask the rabbi. Criticising the government


Question.  What right do we have to criticize a democratically elected government? Surely Judaism believes in loyalty to duly appointed leaders.

Answer.     Judaism does not support the early Christian doctrine,

“Render unto God the things that are God’s and to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s” (Matt. 22:21).

We do not distinguish between the spiritual and temporal. We do not accept that Caesar (i.e. the government) is a law unto itself.

Despite Jeremiah’s advice,

“Seek the peace of the city” (Jer. 29:7) and the rule in Pirkei Avot, “Pray for the welfare of the government” (Avot 3:2),

the government is not always right. It is not true that the king can do no wrong.

Loyalty has to be given and laws obeyed, but not unthinkingly. We do not suspend moral judgment and accept every government policy simply because the government is the government. When necessary we have to echo the words of the three youths in the Book of Daniel,

“Be it known to you, O King, that we will not serve your gods, or worship the golden images you have set up” (Dan. 3:18).

Credit: www.dailymail.co.uk

In totalitarian places and times, it was almost impossible to topple a regime that imposed unjust rules upon its subjects, and resistance to government decrees could well require martyrdom. In democracies, however, the power of the ballot box enables citizens to replace a government of which the majority disapproves. Yet there may be a long wait until the next election, and in any case a government might survive even though the moral strength is with the minority.

But here another principle of democracy comes into play – the right to free association and free speech. When a government policy conflicts with the eternal verities grounded in the Bible, democratic means of protest and persuasion are available.

Governments do listen and are not without a sense of the right thing. Agreed, those who protest too much can sometimes suffer victimization, however subtle. But even if there is a risk in speaking out, we cannot live with our conscience if we opt for a quiet life and remain silent.


Question. Is it wrong for a father and son to have the same first name?

Answer.    It was certainly done in ancient times. The Apocrypha records that Tobit called his son Tobias:

“When I came of age I took a wife from our kindred, and had a son by her whom I named Tobias” (Tobit 1:9).

Josephus had a brother whose name was Matityahu ben Matityahu:

“I was born to Matityahu… I was brought up with my brother, whose name was Matityahu” (Life of Flavius Josephus 1, 2).

Elsewhere Josephus refers to Chananiah ben Chananiah and Yochanan ben Yochanan (Antiquities 20:9:2, 10:1:2). Talmudic literature refers to Chanina ben Chanina, Bonias ben Bonias, Leizer ben Leizer, Yosef ben Yosef, Chiyya ben Chiyya, Ba bar Ba, etc.

The custom was and is maintained by the Sephardim, but the Ashkenazim prefer not to name a child after a living relative. Sometimes an Ashkenazi child is given his father’s first name if the father has already died.


Artwork by Jakob Steinhardt. Rabbis Studying Torah, Made of Woodcut

Question.  Our community is starting a Kollel. What is a Kollel and why does it have that name?

Answer.    It is a community of Torah scholars for advanced study and research, akin to a postgraduate facility at a university.

The name is from a root that means “to include” and it stands for a close-knit community. There could also be a link with the Talmudic institution of “Yarchei Kallah”, months of kallah, i.e. “K’nesset Lom’dei HaTorah” – “Assembly of Students of the Torah”.


Rabbi Apple served for 32 years as the chief minister of the Great Synagogue, Sydney, Australia’s oldest and most prestigious congregation. He was Australia’s highest profile rabbi and held many public roles. He is now retired and lives in Jerusalem.
Rabbi Apple blogs at http://www.oztorah.com

Check Also

The Jewish countdowns – Shavu’ot

THE JEWISH COUNT-DOWNS The countdown to Shavu’ot is the 49 days of the Omer. Beginning …