An Open Letter to the Muslim World.

Written and posted with the permission of Rabbi Simon Jacobson of the Meaningful Life Center .


 An Open Letter to the Muslim World.

What Would Your Grandfather Say?

— An informal entry in my personal blog today —

Dear Cousin,

Muslims praying in a Mosque in Syria. Wikipedia.

As relatives that go back thousands of years to our shared grandfather Abraham, let me get straight to the point.

You are all believers of Allah — a good G-d who created all human beings with the purpose of transforming this world with virtue and justice.

You proudly trace your lineage to Ishmael son of Abraham — the one and only Abraham who stood up to an entire pagan world and single-handedly pioneered the path of kindness and love, as documented in the Torah (what you call Tawrat).

So here is my question to you: With atrocities being perpetrated by Muslims in the name of Allah — mass beheadings, rapes and murders of women and children, the killings of thousands of innocent people — why do we not hear any voice of protest from any of you?

Some argue that you silently condone and agree with this behavior. Others say that you may not advocate this violent approach of creating an Islamic Caliphate and would prefer that it be done peacefully, but you can understand and therefore tolerate your fellow Muslims who do embrace these militant methods.

We prefer to believe that 1.5 billion of you do not approve of these methods. But if that is the case, why are none of you — not individually and not collectively, not your laymen and not your leaders –crying out in outrage?! Why are your Imams silent about this in their weekly Kutbahs (sermons)?

How about your children: What are they being told about these brutal methods?

And finally, the biggest question of all: Did you ever think what your grandfather and ancestor — the founder of your faith — would say about this behavior?

When Abraham became aware of G-d’s plan to destroy the infidel cities of Sodom and Gomorrah, what did he do? One would have perhaps thought that Abraham would have celebrated the annihilation of the non-believers, the apostates and the sinners. But no! We are told — and you can read it in your very own Qur’an — that Abraham prayed for them, beseeching G-d to spare the city in merit of the righteous people that may live there!

So please explain: How is it possible that instead of following Abraham’s path of compassion, instead of praying for (people you consider to be) infidels, you are murdering them in cold blood?!

How can anyone claiming to be Abraham’s child — the very Abraham who introduced love and kindness to the world; the very same Abraham who prayed for an infidel nation — behead another human being?!

The basis of Islam, built upon the Torah, states that every human being is created in the Divine Image. How then can someone claiming to be a believer gruesomely murder the… Divine Image, while crying out Allahu Akhbar, God is the greatest?!…

Is this what Abraham sacrificed his life for, so that his grandchildren would in his name and in the name of G-d terrorize the world?!

How would your grandfather Abraham react to your actions??

Editor’s note: Offensive comments will be deleted.


Check Also

Yes, truly, Israel is not Canada- Opinion

We, like you, treasure democracy, humaneness, justice, and civil and human rights. We are not …


  1. Whilst I’m sure Rabbi Jacobson knows about Jewish theology, his statement “The basis of Islam, built upon the Torah, states that every human being is created in the Divine Image” might not be entirely accurate.

    Islam may have borrowed parts of the Torah, but it is by no means built upon the Torah. Also, the koran seems to suggest that Muslims have a superior place and only they are pleasing to Allah. This differs considerably from Judaism and Christianity, which believe we are all made in G-d’s image.

  2. Rabbi Freilich in Western Australia has this to say

    “The moderate Muslim leadership should sign a petition that should be published in all Australian newspapers condemning the murderous behaviour of the extremists of the Islamic faith,” Rabbi Freilich said.

    “This would have a far greater impact on the general community in dispelling any suspicions or misconceptions than a mere petition signed by other faith leaders.”

    Rabbi Freilich said his comments were not meant to be inflammatory and he hoped Muslims would accept them in the spirit they were intended.

    “As a Jew I respect every religion . . . and I would also hope and pray that our Muslim brethren would also take a stance against the persecution of Jews,” he said.

  3. Yes, it would be good if the moderate Muslim leadership made a strong statement, especially those leaders who are involved in massive interfaith initiatives. In Melbourne, the Islamic Council of Victoria are the interfaith partners, yet as soon as the Gaza war started, issued a media release strongly condemning Israel, without mention of Hamas’ constant provocations and acts of war.

    Those Muslim leaders who are truly moderate must make it clear whose side they are on.

    • All leadership, not just moderate.
      When the PM proposed “Team Australia” they whinged they were being targetted.

      NO such thing.!

      They should have been straight on board backing him.

      By not, it looks as if they are backing the IS.

      EVEN Keyser Trad was on board.