Mike Carlton and Glen Le Lievre cross the line.
By veteran Aussie journalist Mike Carlton in today’s [Melbourne] Age and Sydney Morning Herald, newpapers in the left-liberal Fairfax stable, accompanied by an unmistakably antisemitic cartoon by Glen Le Lievre for good measure:
“….Yes, Hamas is also trying to kill Israeli civilians, with a barrage of rockets and guerilla border attacks. It, too, is guilty of terror and grave war crimes. But Israeli citizens and their homes and towns have been effectively shielded by the nation’s Iron Dome defence system, and so far only three of its civilians have died in this latest conflict. The Israeli response has been out of all proportion, a monstrous distortion of the much-vaunted right of self defence.
It is a breathtaking irony that these atrocities can be committed by a people with a proud liberal tradition of scholarship and culture, who hold the Warsaw Ghetto and the six million dead of the Holocaust at the centre of their race memory….”
Carlton’s is a false analogy. He should remember that in the Second World War the United States dropped more bombs on Germany (millions of tons) than Germany dropped on the United States (zero).
Does Carlton think that this was a disproportionate use of American power?
He should also reflect that Hamas denies Israel’s right to exist, and is indeed sworn in its covenant to the genocide not only of Jews in Israel but in the Diaspora as well. It is impossible to negotiate with extremists like that.
First posted at the Daphne Anson Blog.